top of page
View of Gatsby's and the beach on Fire Island, NY

Gatsby's

The Ultimate

Large-Group

Luxury Retreat

on Fire Island

SLEEP 26 | HEATED SALTWATER POOL | TWO HOT TUBS | STEPS TO THE BEACH

Gatsbys Highlights updated.png

Gatsby's is a one-of-a-kind Ocean Bay Park retreat designed for large group getaways, with seven bedrooms, five full bathrooms, and accommodations for up to 26 guests. Just steps from the beach and ferry, the home, with 20 5-star reviews on Airbnb and Vrbo, features two fully equipped kitchens, expansive indoor and outdoor gathering spaces, a heated saltwater plunge pool, two private hot tubs, multiple oceanview decks, and all the comforts needed for an unforgettable stay on Fire Island.

Gatsby's Availability

The Gatsby's house identified in yellow right next to the beach

Inquire About Gatsby's

Preferred Contact Method
Reason for prospective stay
A Gatsby's living room area

Hospitality Beyond
Hosting

Most rentals provide just access. Gatsby's, situated next to Ocean Bay Park on Fire Island, provides access and service.

From the moment you inquire until the day you depart, we're here to make every detail effortless. 

Personalized communication, local expertise, and concierge level care are all included.

The beach next to Gatsby's
One of the decks at Gatsby's, this one with blue armchairs with yellow pillows
One of the bedrooms at Gatsby's, this one with a window at the head of the bed looking to the beach
Gatsby's oversized Adirondack roof chairs
The owners' dog, Red

The Chairs (and Dog)
Everyone Talks About

Perched above Ocean Bay Park on Fire Island, our oversized Adirondack chairs have become one of the property's, and the area's, gathering spots and characteristics to chat about.

And Red? Well, he's a celebrity around these parts so feel free to say hi.

Gatsby's Photo Gallery

Gatsby's Gathering Icons
bottom of page