Made for the kind of Fire Island stays you never want to end, Gatsby’s welcomes up to 24 guests with over six bedrooms, five full bathrooms, and endless opportunities to spend time together. From the heated plunge pool and two private hot tubs to multiple ocean-view decks and two full kitchens, everything is designed around gathering, relaxing, and enjoying the island.
Gatsby's Availability
Inquire About Gatsby's
Hospitality Beyond
Hosting
The home may bring you to Gatsby’s, but the experience is what sets your stay apart. We believe hospitality is everything that happens around where you stay—the thoughtful details, personal attention, and care that make your time on Fire Island feel effortless.
From your first conversation with us to your ferry home, every Gatsby’s stay is supported by personalized attention, trusted local expertise, and concierge-level care—because how you experience your stay matters just as much as where you stay.
The Chairs (and Dog)
Everyone Talks About
Perched on Gatsby’s third-level deck overlooking Ocean Bay Park, our oversized Adirondack chairs have become something of a landmark of their own. Impossible to miss and even harder to forget, they’re a favorite conversation piece—and an even better place to settle in and take in the view from above.
And then there’s Redd. Somewhere along the way, he became just as recognizable as the chairs. He’s a familiar face around Ocean Bay Park and always seems to make a few new friends, so if you see him around, be sure to say hello.
Gatsby's Photo Gallery
